Two men act out a fierce psychological rivalry for two hours, only to cave in instantly to a females glib tonguelashing. The celluloid closet 1995 letterboxd your life in film. The directors are jeffrey friedman and rob epstein. This movie gives the audience a great insight of what it like to make a movie like that in hollywood. However, the celluloid closet generously commends the increasingly progressive representations of homosexuality. After watching the documentary, my eyes were opened to hollywoods extensive history of predominantly stereotyping and. The celluloid closet is based on how motion pictures especially hollywood films had portrayed gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender characters in cinema. Though some crirics have complained that russo ignored social theory in his analysis, or that he failed to consider important gay directors such as eisenstein and fassbinder, the celluloid closet is still a fascinating and informative book. The final scene is the weakest in the film, and borden chase reportedly hated it, with good reason. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Russo had researched the history of how motion pictures, especially hollywood films, had portrayed gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender characters. The celluloid closet is a manifesto, a road map and a mideighties view from the trenches on the struggle for visibility, viability, representation and social and artistic expressions of gender, sexuality and difference that are still.
The celluloid closet movie analysis 836 words 4 pages. Mar 05, 20 celluloid was the first plastic used to make movie film, so even today, the word celluloid is often used to mean movies. The celluloid closet 1995 1 sheet the celluloid closet 1995 see all 9 photos. Film explores homosexuality in the movies hartford. A valuable appendix to the childrens hour is the incredible documentary the celluloid closet, based on the book by film. It is an old stereotype, that homosexuality has to do only with sex while heterosexuality is multifaceted and embraces love and romance. The celluloid closet movie analysis 836 words bartleby. The celluloid closet 1995 journeys in classic film. The vito russo test takes its name from celebrated film historian and glaad cofounder vito russo, whose book the celluloid closet remains a foundational analysis of lgbtq portrayals in hollywood film. Before the celluloid closet, epstein and friedman won oscars for two other gaythemed documentaries, the life of harvey milk and common threads.
As such, the celluloid closet draws our attention to where the traces of gay sexuality are in supposedly heterosexual stories. This film depicts the characterization of gays and lesbians throughout 100 years of hollywood films. The film presents dozens of authorities, directors, producers. Queer coding and documentary film practice in the celluloid closet. The celluloid closet i find this documentary does well to illustrate the under representation of homosexuals in hollywood and the media in general. Eves talk, and the musical accompaniment mirrors, in microcosm, all the ways in which the celluloid closet has changed. The celluloid closet debuted in 1995 at the venice film festival. Nov 29, 2018 we look at the history of the gay character in film and how they were hidden before and during the hays codes. The celluloid closet functions as a multipurpose wonder. Its not a marxist, feminist, semiotic analysis that only another academic whose specialty is film is going to be able to sift through. My analysis on the celluloid closet film, gender, and. The filmmakers examine the subtext of more than 100. The celluloid closet packs a lot of movie history into less than two hours, as producerdirectors rob epstein and jeffrey friedman chronicle the roles of gays and lesbians from two men. The celluloid closet is a documentary that dares to go where others havent gone before.
The film also benefits from the new medium, being able to. The celluloid closet moves chronologically, beginning with silent films that featured simpering gay characters clarence, the clerk one of. The film depicts how hollywood has taught straight people. Russo, a writer and film historian who was close to both epstein and tomlin, and had hoped to participate in the making of this film before he died of aids in 1991, developed the celluloid closet. The granddaddy of them all amos lassen vito russos the celluloid closet is one of the first gay nonfiction books that i read. It is a book about straight images of homosexual people by a liberal gay man. To my knowledge this was the first article to talk about homosexuality in egyptian film and to nuance it along the same lines argued by vito russo in his 1981 book the celluloid closet which was made into an eponymous, mustsee. Hollywood films rarely depict gay and lesbian protagonists. On a surface level celluloid closet is a style of documentary that discusses the representation, misrepresentation, and lack of representation of homosexuality in hollywood films.
Mar 30, 2015 fox and his friends, scene analysis the celluloid closet then and now the apple 1998 commentary and critique. What we remember with red river is not, however, the silly ending, but the setup and the majestic central portions. These criteria can help guide filmmakers to create more multidimensional characters, while also providing a barometer for representation on a. The celluloid closet is an eye opening documentary about the unjust representation of the gay and lesbian community in film. The celluloid closet is a documentary directedwritten by rob epstein and jeffrey friedman.
Time has not been kind to the celluloid closet but then, vito russo never had much time for time, either. Mar 09, 2015 the celluloid closet then and now march 9, 2015 march 9, 2015 zachary lynch the celluloid closet 1996, is a historical documentary that traces depictions of homosexuality within hollywood cinema, highlighting the accompanying misrepresentation and resulting cultural assertions. We can take this as a significant indication of the parameters of her study, setting it clearly off as a contribution to queer rather than gay film analysis. Beyond the celluloid closet oppression and marginalization representation impact representations we see in movies shape how we view others especially for the. Each individual chapter features a concise overview of the topic at hand, a discussion of representative films, figures, and movements, and an indepth analysis of a single film, including the lion king, the jazz singer, smoke signals, the grapes of wrath, and the celluloid closet. For 9yearold me, though, what mattered was it was the first film i ever saw in which the word fuck was uttered. This documentary highlights the historical contexts that gays, lesbians, bisexuals and transgenders have occupied in cinema history, and shows the evolution of the entertainment industrys role in shaping perceptions of lgbt figures. Since the beginning of the cinematic art, queer predominantly cisgender. Based on a 1981 book by vito russo and narrated by lily tomlin, the film states upfront that in one hundred years of. The queer german cinema does not list vito russos the celluloid closet new york.
The celluloid closet quotes by vito russo goodreads. Hes got something to be rebellious about, namely being gay in a homophobic society. Stories from the quilt, documakers rob epstein and jeffrey friedman have been instrumental in. This movie gives the audience a great insight of what it like to make a movie like that in. The vito russo test takes its name from celebrated film historian and glaad cofounder vito russo, whose book the celluloid closet remains a foundational analysis of early lgbtq portrayals in hollywood film. Timewarner earned massive amounts of money from the release of batman in 1989, not just from boxoffice revenue, but also from merchandise sold at timewarner outlet stores, from the soundtrack album distributed by timewarner music, and by selling tv exhibition rights to timewarner cable. The jcc in manhattan eve siculars opus, the yiddish celluloid closet, is a rainbow quilt of all these discrete, but connected jewish identities. Russo, the celluloid closet 53 particular way of making sense of the body and the ineluctable practices of social construction tend to be too areat, and it is hard not to put too great an em a society in which the possibilities of the body are radically, differently understood and cherished. It is based on vito russos groundbreaking 1981 study, which he updated in 1986. The reason why i wrote the celluloid closet in the style that i did was to make it accessible to a large readership. In oscarwinning films such as the times of harvey milk and common threads. The film is based on the 1981 revised 1987 book of the same name written by vito russo, and on previous lecture and film clip presentations given in person by russo 197282. The issues addressed include secrecy which initially defined homosexuality as well as the demonization of the homosexual community with the advent. In 1981, when russo first published the celluloid closet, an unprecedented analysis of homosexuality in mainstream film, it was illegal to be gay in many states.
The celluloid closet is about 100 minutes long, and manages to cram in countless clips, stills and comments about a huge variety of movies that are about homosexuality, or deal with some aspect of gay life. Derived from the book of the same name by the late gay film critic vito russo. The celluloid closet a history of gays in the cinema the. In it are interviews with directors actors and actresses and at times they share a hindsight about a lack of knowledge in what their actions were and how they impacted. The celluloid closet and stereotypes documenting myths 10. The rerelease of the celluloid closet, originally screened in 1995 on channel 4, is based on vito russos groundbreaking study, the celluloid closet published in 1981, and reissued in 1987. I cant imagine a better thoughtout analysis of the predicament of gays and lesbians and their presentation in film in the pre and immediate poststonewall era of the cinema. If youre transgender, the joke in this scene is on you. Through the use of interviews with homosexual actors and filmmakers, as well as straight actors who played gay roles, we gained insight on their opinions regarding how. The celluloid closet is a 1995 american documentary film directed and written by rob epstein and jeffrey friedman. Throughout the documentary highprofile celebrities such as tom hanks and susan sarandon are interviewed regarding their opinion on the topic. Legendary gay film scholar vito russo once said, well get our rights when we take them. These criteria can help guide filmmakers to create more multidimensional characters while also providing a barometer for representation on.
Fassbinder and fassbinder as fox fassbinder is widely renowned for his films criticality of traditional social, political, and economic norms while fox and his friends is. The celluloid closet is a 1996 american documentary film directed and written by rob epstein and jeffrey friedman. We look at the history of the gay character in film and how they were hidden before and during the hays codes. The film was given a limited release in select theatres, including. The celluloid closet was directed by rob epstein and jeffrey friedman, who won oscars for their two previous gaythemed docs, the life of harvey milk and common threads. Oct 14, 2009 it is now impossible not to read the film as a story of love between two men, now we know both vidal and wylers intentions.
On the 30th anniversary of publication of vito russos celluloid closet, mark adnum takes a fresh look at this important but. Hollywood, that dream factory, has always been a magnet for the artistic gays and lesbians that have had a lot to endure and have never been recognized to the valuable contributions they have made to the medium. Portrayals of homosexuality were frowned upon until the 1960s, by the movie industrys production code and such groups as the legion of. Hollywood screen depictions of homosexuals and the attitudes behind them throughout the history of north american film.
In this same decade, tv and film gradually expanded its depiction of lgbtq. In the spring of 1998, middle east report published an article by garay menicucci titled unlocking the arab celluloid closet. The celluloid closet 1995 a documentary surveying the various hollywood screen depictions of homosexuals and the attitudes behind them throughout the history of north american film. Mar 09, 2015 the celluloid closet is an indie documentary film that was created in 1995. This documentary highlights the historical contexts that gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender individuals have occupied in cinema history, and shows the evolution of the entertainment industrys role in shaping perceptions of lgbt figures. The celluloid closet is not a materialist feminist book about sexual representation and ideology by a sexual liberation activist. Oct 26, 2018 in particular, vitto russos 1981 book, the celluloid closet speaks to this silencing of lgbtq contributions and absence of genuine representation in film history.
Feb 08, 2010 narrated by lily tomlin, this acclaimed documentary takes its name from vito russos groundbreaking book. Stories from the quilt, documakers rob epstein and jeffrey. The celluloid closet 1995, a documentary based on vito russos book the celluloid closet. Until the late 1960s, the agency regulating films specified that depictions of openly gay and. Like any minority group, the roles for homosexuals have been less than diverse and the celluloid closet, based on the book by vito russo, looks at the role of gay and lesbian characters in film and. On the 30th anniversary of publication of vito russos celluloid closet, mark adnum takes a fresh look at this important but problematic history of queer representation in cinema. The celluloid closet a history of gays in the cinema. Mar 14, 2014 the celluloid closet is an eye opening documentary about the unjust representation of the gay and lesbian community in film. Homosexuality in the movies chronicles the depictions of queer characters throughout the history of cinema, presenting analyses and various critiques of such films by film industry insiders, many of whom are queer themselves. Not all of my readers own a dvd player, so lets start with the film itself before discussing the extras. The celluloid closet, which opens today at the charles, is a fascinating account of how hollywood has dealt with homosexuals and homosexuality through its history. The documentary is a worthy adaptation of the vito russo book, managing to include and expand on many of the ideas from the book. The celluloid closet takes a thoughtprovoking look at the decades of omission and misrepresentation endured by the gay community in mainstream cinema.
A brief history of queer coding in cinema film history. The celluloid closet 1996, is a historical documentary that traces depictions of homosexuality within hollywood cinema, highlighting the accompanying misrepresentation and resulting cultural assertions. The celluloid closet homosexuality in movies vito russo. And he of course has to be killed thats what happens to real rebels in our society. Films featured in the celluloid closet, a list of films by. The film also benefits from the new medium, being able to show scenes that russo could only describe.
Harper and row, 1981 in its extensive bibliography. The celluloid closet movie analysis 836 words 4 pages the celluloid closet is a documentary directedwritten by rob epstein and jeffrey friedman. The celluloid closet was released in 1995 and was directed by academy award winner rob epstein and jeffery friedman. The celluloid closet in oscarwinning films such as the times of harvey milk and common threads. Hollywood, that dream factory, has always been a magnet for the artistic gays and lesbians that have had a lot to endure and have never been recognized to the valuable contributions they have made to. The celluloid closet, by vito russo bright lights film. This film containsdiscusses examples of the following tropes. The book was adapted into a documentary of the same name in 1995 by rob epstein and jeffrey friedman. The celluloid closet is an indie documentary film that was created in 1995. The celluloid closet has just made its debut on dvd and its extras are worth checking out even if you have already seen, or own, the film on videotape. The celluloid closet, which opens today at the charles, is a. I think that the title celluloid closet refers to the movie world and the closet that gays supposedly hide in. The celluloid closet 1995 is a very entertaining documentary that chronicles the often tainted depiction of gays and lesbians on the silver screen. In particular, vitto russos 1981 book, the celluloid closet speaks to this silencing of lgbtq contributions and absence of genuine representation in film history.
785 75 1525 1269 100 187 280 1001 1482 875 127 1380 355 744 1013 118 1375 314 187 645 1429 59 1254 259 1292 1071 1186 1075 1349 761 1041